Skip to main content

Johnny Frank Garrett and the Murder of Sister Benz

More than half of the United States still use the death penalty. It is also still used in federal and military cases. However, there are strict laws regarding when the use of the death penalty is appropriate, legally speaking. It is not something that is handled lightly, in most cases. It is also reserved for the most heinous of crimes. The death penalty is considered for nothing short of murder. Nonetheless, there are times when there is doubt as to whether the death penalty was the right punishment or if the party was even guilty of the crimes that resulted in the death penalty. Such was the case with Johnny Frank Garrett.

Johnny Frank Garrett was 17-years-old when he allegedly raped and murdered a 76-year-old nun in a nunnery. He reportedly broke into the convent, entered Sister Benz's room, raped her and killed her. One piece of evidence against him was an alleged confession that he never signed and of which there are no audio recordings. Other evidence included a clairvoyant pointing the finger at Johnny and Johnny's fingerprints at the scene. According to "The Last Word," a documentary about Garrett, Garrett had been in the convent helping move furniture within a few weeks of the murder.

Other evidence at the site of the Benz murder included black curly hairs that clearly did not belong to the straight-haired Caucasian Johnny Frank Garrett and which did not match the victim, a t-shirt that evidently did not belong to Johnny and an officer seeing Johnny near the convent that night. Johnny Frank Garrett lived across the street from the convent. Two knives were found at the scene, one was a butter knife with Garrett's prints on it, but neither was used to kill the nun. Police discarded DNA evidence found at the scene. The State of Texas even threatened to sue Garrett's surviving family members if they asked for the DNA in a court of law.

A few outside factors make the Johnny Frank Garrett case even more intriguing. Other elderly women in the area had recently been raped and murdered in a very similar way. Johnny was not guilty of those crimes. Another man later confessed to killing the nun and was convicted of other killings. He also claimed the white t-shirt found at the scene of the crime was his. The very church that was traumatized by the elderly nun's death argued against the death penalty in Garrett's case. Not only was he just 17 when he was tried, he was also allegedly mentally handicapped and he may well have been innocent.

Johnny Frank Garrett supposedly committed murder in 1981. Eleven years later, he was put to death by lethal injection. He maintained his innocence until his death. Without any clear DNA evidence, there is no telling if Johnny Frank Garrett was truly guilty. However, there remains the question of whether there was enough evidence to convict him and whether executing a person with mental disabilities is morally correct.

Sources

Actual Innocence: Johnny Frank Garrett and Bubbles the Clairvoyant, retrieved 5/13/11, skepticaljuror.com/2010/04/fine-folks-of-amarillo-wanted-justice.html

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Dena Riley and Richard Davis: Sadistic Serial Killer Couple

Richard Davis and Dena Riley were drug-crazed serial killers willing to do the unthinkable. They were the classic killer couple, feeding off each other's depravity and, in the case of Dena, willing to do anything to please her partner. There were few lines this duo did not cross, even though their killing spree was relatively short and included comparatively few victims. Richard "Ricky" Davis was a repeat sex offender and general lawbreaker who was raised in Kansas City. He was institutionalized as a teenager. Later, he was imprisoned for stealing. Within months of his release, he was back in prison for raping a woman at knifepoint. He was sentenced to 25 years but was released in May of 2005 after roughly 18 years. For nine months after his release, Ricky Davis catered to a bondage, strangulation and sexual murder fetish with pornography. At the same time, he attended sex counseling, drug counseling and kept in touch with his parole officer religiously.

San Francisco's Zebra Murders

Art Agnos, San Francisco Mayor targeted by Zebra Killers The Zebra Murders were a series of racially motivated yet seemingly random murders and attacks that took place in San Francisco in 1973 and 1974.. The perpetrators of these murders and violent attacks were dubbed the "Zebra Killers." The San Francisco press originated the term Zebra Killers/Murders. The name stuck, and even the police picked it up, using channel Z on their radios strictly for the Zebra case. The designation may have had something to do with the fact that the killings appeared to be committed by black people against white people. The first known Zebra Murder took place on October 19, 1973. A young married couple, Quita and Richard Hague, were out walking in San Francisco when two young, well-dressed black men assaulted them. They were forced into a white van. Quita was sexually assaulted and then stabbed in the neck several times with a machete. Her head was nearly severed. After watching his wife be

Charles Starkweather: Spree Killer

Charles Starkweather's Mug Shot Charles Starkweather was an American spree killer who personified the pop-culture image of the rebel without a cause who runs away with his lover and kills everyone who gets in their way. Romantic, right? Quite frankly, it is not even romantic when they do it on television but when Charles Starkweather did it, it was outright disgusting. There was nothing romantic or inspiring about it. Charles Starkweather was born to Guy and Helen Starkweather on November 24, 1938. He was third of the couple's seven children. Guy and Helen raised their children on a very small income in Lincoln, Nebraska. Guy was a carpenter, who was often out of work because of arthritis. Helen was a waitress who worked hard to make ends meet. According to everyone, including Charles, his parents were not abusive, he never went hungry and he always had clothes on his back. Charles was born with a few impairments. He had a small speech impediment, bowed legs and h